Trending

A Late Game Twist Complicates Assassin’s Creed: Valhalla’s Gay Representation

Despite how it appears, Eivor's gender isn't just a switch you can flip.

Assassin’s Creed: Valhalla and I were getting along so well, but now I’m not sure how I should feel about the 90 hours I spent playing it. This is because a reveal in Ubisoft’s take on Norse mythology completely recontextualizes everything about protagonist Eivor. And I guess the simplest way to put it is the viking isn’t who I thought he was. The version I was playing of him was a gay man, but as I progressed further into Valhalla and put the pieces together of how this character played into Assassin’s Creed’s larger story, I began to fear I had been seeing a distorted view of this person. Like an unreliable narrator guiding me along that I wasn’t going to be clued into until it was too late. And while some care was taken to not reveal that truth to me on my playthrough, Assassin’s Creed: Valhalla does have an idea of who Eivor is, and that’s a reality no amount of player agency can escape.

Spoilers for Assassin’s Creed: Valhalla follow. Reader discretion is advised.

At the beginning of Assassin’s Creed: Valhalla, you’re given a choice to play as either a male or female version of Eivor. The in-universe explanation for this is the Animus, the virtual reality simulator that allows you to explore people’s memories through their DNA, is picking up on two competing personalities: one male, one female. You can decide to hone in on one or the other, and that’s how you decide what Eivor’s appearance will be throughout. While that alone doesn’t seem to make much sense in the moment, what makes it weirder is that you’re able to switch between the two at will throughout the game, and it won’t have any actual effect on the narrative. Characters you’ve met won’t remark on your changed appearance and the game doesn’t lock any content based on Eivor’s gender, including romances. But on top of that, there’s a third option that will switch between the two when their strands are stronger, which defaults to female Eivor for a majority of the game, switching to male Eivor for very specific circumstances.

Despite the seemingly improbable nature of it all, Ubisoft confirmed both male and female Eivor were canon in some way before Valhalla launched, and there was a justification for how this was possible. But when you see how it’s all explained in Assassin’s Creed’s extremely elaborate world, the reason of it, while an interesting twist on paper, has wider ramifications about Valhalla’s queer representation, specifically impacting the possibility of Eivor being a gay man. This technically also has an impact on Eivor being a straight man, but we’re talking about Assassin’s Creed’s already messy relationship with depicting queer people here.

Near the beginning of Valhalla, Eivor has visions of the Norse god Odin, who is shown to have some kind of connection to our protagonist, even appearing during crucial assassination scenes and decision points to act as a sort of angel/devil on your shoulder. Notably, Odin looks and sounds suspiciously like the male Eivor. Playing as a man, the implication here seemed obvious to me, and knowing bits of Assassin’s Creed lore prior meant I was aware there was some form of reincarnation in this universe. But let’s put a pin in all this information for a second.

Eventually, a seer uses potions to allow Eivor to make greater sense of their visions of Odin, manifesting as a new map to run around in the seemingly endless open world: Asgard. We play as Odin (or Eivor seeing Odin’s memories, depending on how technical you want to get) in the lead up to Ragnarok, the end of the world in Norse mythology. Like anyone would, he wants a way out and is willing to betray a lot of people to do it. Without getting too in the weeds of how it all works, the long and short of it is the god sacrifices his left eye to be reincarnated after Ragnarok comes to pass. He won’t be able to escape his end in this life, but he’ll get to live on in another. The same goes for a handful of other Norse gods, including Tyr, Thor, and Freya, with Loki doing some scheming to assure he gets to live on as well. 

After living through three of Odin’s memories, it’s revealed that Valhalla is about the reincarnations, or Sages, of the Norse gods. Tyr lives on as Eivor’s step brother Sigurd, although he does lose an arm again in his new life. Loki comes back as Basim, who carries with him a grudge going back to their days in Asgard. And the reason Eivor has such close ties to Odin’s memories is because they are the reincarnation he lost an eye to become. There’s a lot of Assassin’s Creed lore to explain to get the full context of what is actually happening here and how it plays into the overarching story of the franchise, but all you really need to know is that Odin was a man who existed a long time ago in this universe, and he ensured he would return in some form in the future because he feared the death of a cataclysmic event, one Eivor processes as Ragnarok.

So now that we know Eivor is a reincarnation of Odin, how does that change things? On its own, that doesn’t change much at all. When it does is how it contextualizes that third choice: the one where the game will switch between male and female Eivor based on whose signal is stronger. As it turns out, the only time male Eivor’s signal strength is stronger is during the Asgard flashback scenes. Otherwise, Eivor is a woman if this is the option you go with.

There’s a reason male Eivor resembles Odin so strongly: he is Odin. These two dueling identities exist in one person, but in the end, Eivor is a woman. She’s the one being represented in comics and novels, and might show up in a Kassandra-style reveal at the end of Valhalla’s DLC and be referenced in future games. This isn’t specifically communicated to a person who plays male Eivor, but it does mean everything you do as a man is actually being done by a woman. but you chose to hone in on Odin’s DNA while using the Animus.

This is all to say, if Eivor is a woman who is more or less being piloted by her male predecessor when you play as a man, in a wild, in-universe way, it retroactively makes Valhalla’s gay romances straight, as they were between a man and a woman, even if the player isn’t privy to that in the moment. The same can can be said for straight relationships as male Eivor because, unbeknownst to you, this is actually engaging in a sapphic relationship.

You may also like:

Assassin’s Creed has had a pretty checkered past when it comes to its queer rep. Assassin’s Creed: Odyssey came under fire when it let the player engage in same-sex pairings in the main game, only to force player characters Kassandra or Alexios into a heterosexual relationship in order to have a child, then somehow get recognized by GLAAD for its representation. After backlash and an apology, Ubisoft made changes to the storyline in question to make the relationship optional, but kept the child and the deed doing that brought them into the world as a requirement. It all was tied to the series’ emphasis on bloodlines, but when you spend an entire game allowing players to roleplay one way, it flies in the face of the game’s and the player’s interpretation of characters if you require them to enter an opposite-sex relationship.

I don’t really know how to feel about the situation, given that a lot of this isn’t at all communicated to people who play as male Eivor exclusively. There’s even a scene where Eivor renounces Odin’s influence, and when the god is no longer lurking in his mind, Eivor doesn’t magically revert to her true form unless you as the player make the choice for her to. But I would have hoped that after the stumbles Odyssey made Ubisoft would have been more careful going into the game that followed. I don’t look at this and see it as a “gotcha” moment, where folks at Ubisoft were thinking it would be a twist ending where they would pull the rug out from other people and say “you were playing as a woman the entire time!” But it does fundamentally change the entire game for some people, and while I’m less inclined to worry about straight men because they always get to play as characters like them in AAA games, queer men are often the last to get a seat at the table, even in franchises that are ostensibly progressive.

Divorced of context and the knowledge that a player will be engaging in romantic and sexual relationships that will likely resemble their own, it all sounds like a clever way to try to legitimize both versions of Valhalla’s protagonist, but when you don’t go all the way with validating different permutations, you do ultimately undermine them in the end. It just feels even worse when you find out about it so many hours after the fact, and now I have to wrestle with what it all meant to me now that it’s over. I came here to be a gay viking, dammit.

Tags

Kenneth Shepard

Kenneth is a Staff Writer at Fanbyte. He still periodically cries about the Mass Effect trilogy years after it concluded.

Related Articles

20 Comments

  1. I think you may be ignoring the possibility of an intersex, nonbinary, or transgender character. The truth is that DNA doesn’t always line up with external gender presentation, even in times before medical transitions. If you were playing as someone who presents and identifies as male, the fact that the animus detected “female” DNA possibilities doesn’t necessarily mean you were a woman all along. That’s making the huge assumption that XX = Woman. And that’s not always the case. Intersex people who are XX and identify as men do exist, many of whom have facial hair (as male Eivor does). There’s no reason that Eivor can’t be one of them, especially with the semi-magical/advanced-tech intervention of Odin’s DNA insertion. Often intersex conditions that make XX people be designated as male at birth are the result of hormonal conditions in the womb, but Norse gods interfering could also do the trick.

    Also, maybe Eivor is trans-masculine. They’d still be a gay man, in that case, just a trans gay man. Those do exist, after all. It’s not “ahah, you were a woman all along” when a character is revealed to be trans.

    But you’re also leaving out the possibility that they are legitimately genderfluid and/or fall under the nonbinary category. Magic (well, of tech indistinguishable from magic) exists in this world, including Seidr magic. Historically, Seidr magic engages ideas of men needing to “become women” in order to practice it, and Norse deities including both Odin and Loki are described as changing their forms and genders. Loki infamously both fathered children and gave birth to them — so clearly in the mythologies these were complete transformations. I see no reason to believe that Eivor couldn’t be also switching between genders or consider themself to be third gender in some way… if that’s how you wanted to play it. But if you’re keeping one binary gender presentation the whole way through, then biology really doesn’t need to come into it.

    1. I’m not ignoring those possibilities. That’s simply not the scenario and interpretation I was writing about.

  2. I am a gay Viking! Well, sometimes bi. I guess I’ll hook up with just about anybody who gives me the slightest eye. I’ve only played as female Eivor and am in a monogamous relationship with another female (except when I’m on the road, then it’s not really cheating, right?)

  3. I don’t think that’s how reincarnation works. A Man can be a woman 48465742 another life, and vise versa. Even if Odin’s male dna is stronger in those sequences, it’s only because of the DNA memory of the bloodline. It’s been passivity explored in Assassin’s Creed Origins as the future protagonist experiences the memories of Bayek, a man in the past.

  4. This is fantastic news for gay trans women.

    I can live my exact experience. Everyone called me by a male name, but I didn’t want to die, so I made a bunch of sacrifices to be myself (a woman) and my love for other women never changed. ;P

  5. Now, this threw up another very interesting question for me that I can not possibly answer since I am a straight man. How do transgender People feel about this game. Isn’t Eivor a Man in a womans body if you play him/her as a man? I think you could interpret playing a man even after Odins influence is gone as playing a transgender character maybe? Which would be cool, since the way you can’t really know that from the beginning opens up this interpretation to people that would never have thought about it otherwise.
    Also, the fact that eivor doesn’t automatically revert to female after the renouncing odin scene makes sense to me. The simulation is based on DNA streams and that scene is more about strength of will. It’s not like your dna will change if you overcome your own weaknesses.

    1. As a nonbinary trans person, I love Eivor as representation. Now, I’m inclined to think of them as an inherently intersex character (having two sets of DNA is a real thing that can happen–it’s called chimerism and is a very rare cause of intersex conditions, though it has been known to happen)… but gender isn’t something that’s actually in your DNA, either now or in Norse culture. Gender is what you’re recognized as in society and by yourself. Norse culture is full of stories of legendary characters who changed gender (especially Loki), and it’s really nice IMO to see that possibility represented.

      But I’m also fine with people playing them as a binary man or binary woman. There are a LOT of intersex people who live as and embrace the gender they were assigned at birth, and many intersex people don’t even realize that their DNA and their presentation don’t line up in a binary way until a doctor tells them so. But seeing the distinction between DNA and gender in a video game is still remarkably progressive.

  6. This article is interesting and really well written. As soon as I realised the truth of what the animus was presenting us I didn’t really think about the flip side about playing a gay male Eivor as I played Eivor as wlw. When I first played the game I was more pissed off that Ubisoft once again chose to once again make the female protagonist “canon” and that once again they didn’t want to market her or give her any sort of meaningful presence whatsoever. I feel like overall the idea to give this narrative a gender choice just feels like a disservice to people who identify as woman and LGBT+.

    1. Cant Odin already be either male or female in his own Lore? I read somewhere he sacrifices none of his power to do so because his power is mostly magical

  7. All i can say is you fooled around and fell in love. Theres no shame in being gay. Just know games have a lot of progression to make before your truly *gay viking* can come to fruition

    1. Arguably in the lore of AC you cannot have an exclusively gay character, as the memory DNA is required from a living relative. Unless they changed that…

      No egg donation, serogates and sperm donation in 800AD

      1. Well they found Eivors grave in Canada, so that’s where they found the dna. Eivor could’ve never had children and it wouldn’t have changed the storyline

  8. I believe Evior was intended to be female at the start, but since rpg aspects came in, you got to choose. There was a slip up from one of the quest npc’s when i was doing the quest to kidnap the eldermens wife and get back his childhood love.
    They said she even when i was playing the male version

    I believe that the isu Norse gods who put their dna into the baby chamber things with the secret ending during the great catastrophe, It would mean that Evior is technically both male and female. As you see though halvi’s memories. And at the end of the game you fight basim or aka loki, so male Evior is the odin trying to “guide” you and female Evior is just another part of odin’s baby pod thing.

    We probably will find more of the Norse gods in future DLC story.

    1. I haven’t made it past the 2nd plant gathering for the dream concoction. I read this article and then read your take on the story. I really just hope I’m not messing the game up by playing only as male Eivor.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.